Should You Invest in Silver Bullion?

- February 5th, 2020

What are the pros and cons of investing in silver bullion? Read on to learn why now may be the time for investors to enter the market.

As with anything in the market, investing in silver bullion has both pros and cons, and what’s appealing to one investor may not be a good choice for another.

Silver just came off a more prosperous year than it has seen in awhile, and as prices rise, many investors interested in the precious metals market are wondering if now is the right time for buying silver bullion. 

While the white metal can be volatile, precious metals like silver and gold are also seen as a safety net — as safe haven assets, they can protect investors in times of uncertainty. With tensions running high, they could be a good choice for those looking to preserve their wealth in these difficult times.

With those factors in mind, let’s look at the pros and cons of buying physical bullion in the form of silver. 

Pros of investing in silver bullion

1. Silver can offer protection — As mentioned, investors often flock to precious metals during times of turmoil. When political and economic uncertainty are rife, legal tender generally takes a backseat to assets like gold and silver. While both gold and silver bullion can be appealing to investors, the white metal tends to get overlooked in favor of individuals investing in gold, even though it plays the same role.

2. It’s tangible money — While cash, mining stocks, bonds and other financial products are accepted forms of wealth, they are essentially still digital promissory notes. For that reason, they are all vulnerable to depreciation due to actions like printing money. Silver bullion, on the other hand, is a tangible asset that is finite. That means that, although it is vulnerable to market fluctuations like other commodities, physical silver isn’t likely to completely crash because of its inherent and real value. Market participants can buy bullion through coins or jewelry, or when they buy silver bullion bars.

Chris Duane, an investor and YouTube figure, has said he puts his metal where his mouth is by liquidating his assets and putting the money into silver bullion when prices get low. He believes that our money system, and indeed our entire way of life, is built on unsustainable debt, and the purpose of investing in silver bullion is to take yourself out of the mathematically inevitable collapse of that system.

3. It’s cheaper than gold — Between gold and silver bullion, the white metal is not only less expensive and therefore more accessible to buy, but it’s also more versatile to spend. That means if you are interested in buying silver coins to use as currency, they’re easier to break than gold because they are lower in value. Just as a US$100 bill can be a challenge to break at the store, divvying up an ounce of gold can be a challenge. As a result, silver bullion is more practical and versatile than physical gold.

Is gold a good hedge investment in 2020?

Read our FREE 2020 outlook report on gold investing!

4. Silver offers higher returns than gold — Because the white metal is worth around 1/79th the price of gold, buying silver bullion is affordable and stands to see a much bigger percentage gain if silver prices go up. In fact, in the past, silver has outperformed gold in bull markets, according to GoldSilver. GoldSilver claims that, from 2008 to 2011, silver gained 448 percent, while gold gained just 166 percent in that same period. It’s possible for an investor to hedge their bets with silver bullion in their portfolio.

5. History is on silver’s side — Silver and gold have been used as legal tender for hundreds and thousands of years, and that lineage lends the metal a sense of stability. Many find comfort in knowing that this metal has been recognized for its value throughout a great deal of mankind’s history, and so there’s an expectation that it will endure while fiat currencies may fall to the wayside. When individuals invest in physical silver, whether that be through silver bars, fine silver, coins or other means, there is a reassurance that its value has and will continue to persist.

6. Silver offers anonymity — Whether you value your privacy or not, silver has the same benefit as cash in that it gives users a degree of anonymity with regards to spending. Not everyone wants all of their transactions to be a part of the public record, and privacy is a necessary component of democracy, according to Glenn Greenwald’s TED Talk. That is another benefit of the white metal.

Cons of investing in silver bullion

1. Lack of liquidity — There is a chance that if you hold physical silver, it may not be immediately liquid. In order to make common purchases such as groceries, you are not able to use bars of silver, so you will need to convert that to currency first, and the ability to sell in a hurry can be an issue. In a jam, pawn shops and jewelers are an option, but not necessarily the best-paying one.

2. Danger of theft — Unlike most other investments, such as stocks, holding silver bullion can leave investors vulnerable to theft. Securing your assets from looting by using a safety deposit box in a bank or a safe box in your home will incur additional costs. Additionally, the more physical assets that reside within your home, the more at risk you are for burglary.

3. Weak return on investment — Although silver bullion may be a good safe haven asset, it may not perform as well as other investments — for example, real estate, or even other metals.

Stocks may also be a better option than silver bullion for some investors. As Randy Smallwood, president and CEO of streaming company Wheaton Precious Metals (TSX:WPM,NYSE:WPM), has said, “Streaming companies will always outperform bullion by itself.” He attributes this to organic growth and dividend payouts that bullion doesn’t provide.

Where is silver headed?

Finally, it is important to look at where analysts believe the white metal is headed.

David Morgan, publisher of the Morgan Report, told the Investing News Network (INN) in mid-2019, “Silver will overtake gold on a percentage return basis once the gold market reaches a certain level. That level is unknown, but US$1,550 is probably a good, educated level based on sentiment in the market when both metals were selling off and moving lower.”

More recently he added, “For 2020 I see (silver) picking up momentum. I see a high of US$22 (per ounce), which is about a 30 percent gain from where we (were) in 2019.”

Independent Speculator’s Lobo Tiggre shares Morgan’s sentiment, and told INN last summer that the white metal will go “bananas” when gold does. At the New Orleans Investment Conference that same year, Tiggre, who is CEO of Louis James LLC, said he still believes in silver’s ascent.

“We haven’t quite slipped on the banana peel yet,” he said. “Silver typically lags gold and then it catches up with gusto.”

Tiggre believes that silver is the better buy than its sister metal gold, and said he was looking to purchase more of the bullion for his own portfolio. “I am not too religious about silver versus gold — they’re pretty interchangeable — but silver is just a better deal right now.”

In terms of prices, FocusEconomics‘ latest consensus forecast indicates that panelists expect silver to average US$17.90 in Q4 2020 before ticking down to an average of US$17.60 in Q4 2021.

With all of these factors in mind, silver investors may want to reflect on the pros and cons from their own personal lens before deciding whether to build up their stockpile of silver bullion. Timing is also an important factor for those who want to reap the benefits of the white metal.

This is an updated version of an article originally published by the Investing News Network in 2016.

Don’t forget to follow us @INN_Resource for real-time news updates!

Securities Disclosure: I, Nicole Rashotte, hold no direct investment interest in any company mentioned in this article.

Is gold a good hedge investment in 2020?

Read our FREE 2020 outlook report on gold investing!

Get the latest Silver Investing stock information

Get the latest information about companies associated with Silver Investing Delivered directly to your inbox.

Silver Investing

Select None
Select All

17 responses to “Should You Invest in Silver Bullion?

  1. Is silver and gold a good investment well don’t listen to anybody you decide, first of all in case you did not know, stay away from t/v adds that are trying to sell you gold coins, the U/S mint has said sales in U/S Gold Eagle coins fell by 67% between February 16th 2016) and February 17th 2017) sales of physical Gold and Silver Are
    collapsing across the entire industry, The world council data also
    shows a large decline in physical precious metals market in 2016
    especially with bars-coins-jewelry the new figures show that U/S Gold Eagles and Silver coins are down 75% although paper gold is
    rising, physical is falling. so is Gold and Silver a good investment, well I definitely know better investments.

  2. The only advantage of turning your paper money into silver is one can not catch on fire and be lost BUT don’t ever expect to make ANY money investing in silver since it only goes up pennies per ounce and loss dollars per ounce.
    Coins are even worse than bars since you pay extra for the “Uncirculated brilliant” and that means you better not ever touch them with your hands and when you get them they better ALL be as perfect as possible and buying the ones that are given even higher ratings cost insane amounts and the only one making a profit would be you great-grandkids when they are old.

    Just look at the last 10 years of the value of bars and coins and you see that if there is any rise in value it is the rise of the sellers price and not that you could sell your silver for a profit.

    As far as storage……well if you buy it you should not live in a place where you have to buy a safe or insurance unless you want to lose even more money and you will never have so much silver or gold that you can’t figure out a place to stash it in your house (no not next to the wood stove or fireplace)

    BUT if you want to buy my 100 oz bar or 100 oz’s of uncirculated coins then you can buy all of it for $5000 with free shipping.

  3. Oh wow, you are so far off in left field. People like me buy silver for when the dollar collapses. We want the price to keep going down to lower the dollar cost average.

    Oh and buying a safe was no problem at all. I need to buy another one in addition 🙂

  4. I stack gold and silver an insurance policy for my grandchildren. I love them!! I am certain that our monetary system will collapse when?? Don’t know but just look at the way our leaders are governing.

  5. Its a question of “when”, not “if”. The global financial system is based on ever increasing amounts of debt. Each new $ of debt adds less and less in economic growth and sucks in more $s to finance it. The endgame outcome is certain, the path is uncertain. Stocks can surely outperform PMs in the interim but tough to imagine the +10yrs of expansion we have already seen is sustainable. Stocks and real estate looks very expensive relative to PMs. I am super leveraged on real estate where I earn a good rental yield but have also been accumulating silver and gold in lieu of keeping cash in the bank. You cannot compare investing in PMs with investing in stocks or real estate, its apples and pears. I would rather invest in silver than keep excess money in the bank. Luckily my silver bullion is highly liquid, I pay 3% over spot for 1kg bars and as long as I store it with my broker (who charges 0.6% annual), I get 2% back on any sales if I need quick fiat ccy. So final net cost is 1% plus storage costs. Im happy to keep my silver with my broker for the next few years until I have a better handle on the global outlook. Long term plan is to take delivery to avoid paying longterm storage costs and have my children inherit the bulk of my PMs. In fact, I dont have any savings accounts for them. I allocate a portion of my PMs to them each month as if I would be saving fiat ccy for them.

    I suspect the value of my PMs during the next economic downturn will be enough to cover most or all of my housing loans. Then I will increase my cashflow and look forward to retirement.

Leave a Reply