• Connect with us
    • Information
      • About Us
      • Contact Us
      • Careers
      • Partnerships
      • Advertise With Us
      • Authors
      • Browse Topics
      • Events
      • Disclaimer
      • Privacy Policy
    • Australia
      North America
      World
    Login
    Investing News NetworkYour trusted source for investing success
    • North America
      Australia
      World
    • My INN
    Videos
    Companies
    Press Releases
    Private Placements
    SUBSCRIBE
    • Reports & Guides
      • Market Outlook Reports
      • Investing Guides
    • Button
    Resource
    • Precious Metals
    • Battery Metals
    • Base Metals
    • Energy
    • Critical Metals
    Tech
    Life Science
    Base Metals Market
    Base Metals News
    Base Metals Stocks
    • Base Metals Market
    • Base Metals News
    • Base Metals Stocks
    copper investing

    Design Failure Caused the Mount Polley Disaster

    Charlotte McLeod
    Feb. 01, 2015 07:45PM PST
    Base Metals Investing

    A panel’s determination of the cause of the breach matches the results of an investigation conducted by Mount Polley Mining, the mine’s operator.

    It’s been nearly six months since the tailings storage facility (TSF) at Imperial Metals’ (TSX:III) Mount Polley copper-gold mine was breached, releasing tailings into the surrounding area. However, the public is only now receiving answers about what went wrong

    The Mount Polley Independent Expert Engineering and Review Panel, which is comprised of three geotechnical experts and was formed on the day of the breach, released its final report on the cause on Friday, noting that “the breach was the result of a failure in the foundation of the embankment, a failure that occurred in a glaciolacustrine (GLU) layer of the embankment’s foundation.”

    That might sound confusing, but a recent CBC article provides a good breakdown of the report, explaining that, put simply, the disaster was caused mainly by design failure. Specifically, the design of the TSF “failed to take into account the complexity of the unstable underlying glacial and pre-glacial layers under the retaining wall.”

    While not initially a problem, the instability of those layers became an issue as the TSF grew more and more full. Ultimately, the weight of the material in the TSF caused them to give way, with the breach being the result.

    Elaborating to CBC, Jack Caldwell, an expert on tailings dams, said that Knight Piesold, the engineering and consulting firm that designed the TSF, knew what material the TSF was built on, but “misinterpreted … test results and didn’t really understand the nature of the strength, and the nature of how it could get weaker.”

    According to the panel, that all means the breach was not caused by human intervention; regulatory oversight was also not the problem. Indeed, it emphasizes that inspections of the TSF would not have stopped it from failing. Imperial Metals is unsurprisingly pleased with the news, and said in a statement released on Friday that the panel’s determination of the cause of the breach matches the results of an investigation conducted by Mount Polley Mining, the mine’s operator.

    Of course, key questions now are whether other TSFs may also be ticking time bombs, and what can be done to prevent future TSFs from not being built propertly. On that note, the panel includes in its report seven recommendations. They are as follows:

    • Use a phased approach to implement the best available technology at new and existing TSFs. 
    • Improve corporate governance at companies looking to operate TSFs.
    • Expand the requirements for permits for TSFs.
    • Use independent tailings review boards more frequently.
    • Assess current TSFs in the province and determine whether they are at risk.
    • Push the Association of Professional Engineers and Geoscientists of British Columbia to put together guidelines aimed at improving site characterization for tailings dams.
    • Improve safety guidelines for TSFs.

    At close of day Friday, Imperial Metals’ share price was up 6.04 percent, at $8.95. Prior to the breach, it was sitting at $16.80, and immediately after it was at $9.70. The company said Friday that it “continue to make good progress” in repairing the damage done by the breach.

     

    Securities Disclosure: I, Charlotte McLeod, hold no direct investment interest in any company mentioned in this article. 

    Related reading: 

    Imperial Metals Down 42 Percent After Tailings Pond Breach

    imperial metalscopper investingtsx:iii
    The Conversation (0)

    Go Deeper

    AI Powered

    Toxic Spill at Grupo Mexico Mine Turns Rivers Orange

    OTCQB:BBBXF

    Brixton Metals to Acquire the Trapper Gold-Copper Property and Related Royalties Further Expanding its Thorn Project

    Latest News

    Notice of General Meeting

    Empire Metals Limited Announces Interim Results

    CoTec Holdings Corp. Notes HyProMag USA Press Release Regarding Capacity Expansion Concept Study

    Silver47 Highlights Expansive High-Grade Gold and Silver System at the Kennedy Project, Nevada

    FPX Nickel Completes Additional Large-Scale Mineral Processing Pilot Testwork to Produce Awaruite Concentrate to Support Discussions with Prospective EV Battery Supply Chain Partners

    More News

    Outlook Reports

    Resource
    • Precious Metals
      • Gold
      • Silver
    • Battery Metals
      • Lithium
      • Cobalt
      • Graphite
    • Energy
      • Uranium
      • Oil and Gas
    • Base Metals
      • Copper
      • Nickel
      • Zinc
    • Critical Metals
      • Rare Earths
    • Industrial Metals
    • Agriculture
    Tech
      • Artificial Intelligence
      • Cybersecurity
      • Gaming
      • Cleantech
      • Emerging Tech
    Life Science
      • Biotech
      • Cannabis
      • Psychedelics
      • Pharmaceuticals

    Featured Base Metals Investing Stocks

    Empire Metals

    EPMLF

    Corazon Mining

    CZN:AU

    Blackstone Minerals

    BSX:AU

    Osisko Metals: Pure Potential

    OM:CA

    Los Andes Copper

    LA:CA

    Questcorp Mining

    QQQ:CC
    More featured stocks

    Browse Companies

    Resource
    • Precious Metals
    • Battery Metals
    • Energy
    • Base Metals
    • Critical Metals
    Tech
    Life Science
    MARKETS
    COMMODITIES
    CURRENCIES
    ×