Why is Carnallite Valuable?

Carnallite is a less popular potash ore than sylvinite, but it still comes with niche benefits.

Four primary types of potash ore are commonly extracted by miners: polyhalite, langbeinite, sylvinite and carnallite. Sylvinite and carnallite are the most abundant sources of potash, but it’s been said that carnallite is the less desirable of the two.
Part of the reason carnallite tends to find less favor with potash miners is that it cannot be mined using conventional techniques — it is simply too soluble to be mined in a stable way. What’s more, processing carnallite can require more energy than processing sylvinite.
Despite those challenges, carnallite does come with a few niche benefits. Read on to learn more about what they are, and why it can still be valuable to mine carnallite.

The sylvinite process

As mentioned, carnallite is generally harder to mine and process than sylvinite. For that reason, it’s useful to consider sylvinite mining and processing when looking at the value and drawbacks of carnallite.
Sylvinite is made up of the salts potassium chloride and sodium chloride, and has been mined and processed in abundance by major potash companies like Potash Corporation of Saskatchewan (TSX:POT) and Mosaic (NYSE:MOS). The process typically looks like this:

  1. Dig: Potash ore is dug out and brought to the surface via a shaft.
  2. Crush: The ore is crushed, ground and de-slimed.
  3. Float: A flotation process separates potash from a salt mixture.
  4. Spin: Centrifuges separate potash particles from brine.
  5. Crystalize: Potash concentrate is sized, compacted and crystallized.

Those steps are not simple, but are well understood and can easily be used to process sylvinite ore. Many companies prefer sylvinite to carnallite for this reason.

The carnallite process

Unlike sylvinite, carnallite can’t be mined and processed using conventional methods. Solution mining has to be used instead.
Solution mining consists of drilling holes into an ore body and pumping heated water into the deposit. The heated water dissolves carnallite and brine, allowing them to be pumped out through the holes. The pumped solution goes through an evaporation process that removes water and magnesium chloride and leaves behind potassium chloride and sodium chloride.
Because salts go in and out of solution at different temperatures, the potassium chloride and sodium chloride are put into crystallizers where they’re heated at different temperatures to separate the salts. From there, they are processed into their final products, much like in conventional mining.
As for magnesium, because it is the last mineral to leave water, it is removed early in the process and treated separately.

Why do people still mine carnallite?

Availability
It is true that sylvinite is easier to mine and process than carnallite, but miners still extract carnallite simply because it is available. It can be found in deposits that are vastly distributed across the globe in places like the US, Canada, Russia, Germany and parts of the Middle East.
Magnesium by-product
Magnesium is considered a contaminant when processing carnallite, but it can also be seen as an additional commodity. Magnesium is used in everything from personal health supplements to complex alloys for planes. That can make carnallite a great opportunity for miners that want to diversify their market and sell magnesium as a commodity.
Solution mining
In some cases, effective solution mining can be cheaper and faster than conventional mining. It also comes with reduced engineering and safety risks since less digging is required and workers don’t have to enter underground spaces. Solution mining isn’t an exclusive benefit to carnallite, but the process comes with a lot of upside for miners if done properly.
The process is less environmentally invasive as well, requiring less digging and overall space to conduct operations. The caveat here is that solution mining will require higher water inputs than conventional mining.

The bottom line

Sylvinite makes up the majority of the potash market and is great for miners specializing in potash — but carnallite still holds value when solution mining processes are used well. Magnesium, its main by-product, is also a benefit.
This is an updated version of an article originally published by the Investing News Network in 2013.
Don’t forget to follow us @INN_Resource for real-time news updates!
Securities Disclosure: I, Sivansh Padhy, hold no direct investment interest in any company mentioned in this article.

Featured
Western Resources Corp. is pleased to announce that Western Potash Corp. the company’s wholly-owned subsidiary, has received key findings from its upcoming NI 43-101 report for its Milestone Phase I Project in southern Saskatchewan. The Report is based on the expansion of the mine life from 12 years to 40 years and the update of the mining plan. The technical Report is being prepared by March Consulting Associates ...

Western Resources Corp. (TSX: WRX) ("Western" or "the Company") is pleased to announce that Western Potash Corp. ("WPC"), the company's wholly-owned subsidiary, has received key findings from its upcoming NI 43-101 report ("Report") for its Milestone Phase I Project ("The Phase I Project") in southern Saskatchewan. The Report is based on the expansion of the mine life from 12 years to 40 years and the update of the mining plan.

The technical Report is being prepared by March Consulting Associates Inc. ("March"). March is an engineering and project management provider with extensive experience in delivering mining projects across Saskatchewan.

read more Show less
Western Resources Corp. is pleased to report on the overall status of and progress on the Company’s Milestone Potash Phase 1 Project operated by the Company’s wholly-owned subsidiary, Western Potash Corp. and the Company’s gradual phase out of its real estate investments from its business model in order to improve its financial position and refocus its efforts on the successful completion of the Project. Since ...

Western Resources Corp. (TSX: WRX) (the "Company") is pleased to report on the overall status of and progress on the Company's Milestone Potash Phase 1 Project (the "Project") operated by the Company's wholly-owned subsidiary, Western Potash Corp. ("Western"), and the Company's gradual phase out of its real estate investments from its business model in order to improve its financial position and refocus its efforts on the successful completion of the Project.

Since suspending construction of the Project in May of last year, Western has continued advancing and optimizing its mining operations. These are key to securing the remaining project financing required to complete the balance of plant construction. From April 28, 2020, when hot mining started, until its suspension on May 28 this year, Western's operation team has accumulated extensive experience and collected valuable mining data relevant to the application of its innovative solution mining technology. After extensive analysis of the data, and with the help of a number of leading solution mining experts, Western is developing an optimized solution mining plan.

read more Show less

Potash is essential for crop health and economic yields. Here’s a quick look at the four kinds of potash that dominate the market.

Potash is a potassium-bearing nutrient essential for growing healthy, high-yield crops, and there are four kinds that market participants should have on their radar.

These minerals are found in large evaporate deposits from ancient lakes and sea beds, or in rock formations. The top potash-producing countries include Canada, Belarus and Russia.

read more Show less

MARKETS

Markets
TSX20633.27-128.76
TSXV897.13-13.09
DOW34580.08-59.71
S&P 5004538.43-38.67
NASD15085.47-295.85
ASX7241.20+16.00

COMMODITIES

Commodities
Gold1783.44+1.06
Silver22.54+0.03
Copper4.27-0.03
Palladium1816.01+10.01
Platinum936.31+3.31
Oil66.22-0.28
Heating Oil2.10-0.01
Natural Gas4.09+0.04